To make a Timeline story non-clickable, disable the Story Title link.
Go to Timeline Addons >> Timeline Settings >> Stories Settings >> Display read more: No.
Note: To make Timeline story title non-clickable, Read more option button from the story content will be disabled.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/06140/06140d8394eab73befe913c55fb66d0dcd01b8a3" alt=""